Coleman Milne Rosedale MOT reliability

Coleman Milne Rosedales passed their MOT first time 83% of the time across 308 tests in 2025. 307 are still licensed in Great Britain.

First-time pass rate

83%

MOTs analysed

308

Still licensed (GB)

307

Body type

–

Pass rate by year of first registration

Older cars fail more often, so compare a car with others of the same age. Years with very few MOTs can show extreme pass rates, even 0% or 100%, so give more weight to years with more tests.

In detail:

First registered

2020 diesel

24 MOTs

These figures come from 24 MOT tests. That's a fairly small number of cars, so they may not be typical of these cars as a whole.

Passed first time 71%. Typical mileage 25,518 (most between 22,420 and 31,543).

2022: 100% → 2023: 56% → 2024: 79% → 2025: 71%

Most common failures

Condition: has ply or cords exposed (12.5%)
Brake pads: less than 1.5 mm thick (8.3%)
Tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm (8.3%)
Coil spring: fractured or broken (4.2%)
Mirrors: insecure (4.2%)

2020 hybrid

18 MOTs

These figures come from only 18 MOT tests. With so few cars, a single pass or fail changes the percentages a lot, so treat them as a rough guide rather than a true average.

Passed first time 89%. Typical mileage 24,456 (most between 19,532 and 27,804).

2023: 79% → 2024: 89% → 2025: 89%

Most common failures

Condition: has ply or cords exposed (5.6%)
Registration plate lamp(s): inoperative in the case of a single lamp or all lamps (5.6%)

2020 petrol

11 MOTs

These figures come from only 11 MOT tests. With so few cars, a single pass or fail changes the percentages a lot, so treat them as a rough guide rather than a true average.

Passed first time 64%. Typical mileage 35,432 (most between 25,865 and 37,281).

2023: 83% → 2024: 100% → 2025: 64%

Most common failures

Condition: has ply or cords exposed (18.2%)
Headlamp aim: too low (9.1%)
Exhaust system: system insecure (9.1%)
Wipers: does not clear the windscreen effectively (9.1%)

Where 2020 Rosedales fail

Wheels & tyres

16.7%

Brakes

8.3%

Visibility & wipers

8.3%

Exhaust, emissions & leaks

4.2%

Suspension & axles

4.2%

Looking at a particular car?

See its own MOT history, mileage and red flags, compared with these figures. Free.

Based on 2025 initial MOT tests in DVSA's anonymised MOT dataset (cars and light vans). Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Model details: Vehicle data by VehiclesDB.